Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Case Study: How Neera Mahajan finally became a Substack Bestseller after 6 years of trying

She never missed a week since 2020 and was stuck at 950 subscribers. Three changes got her the badge in 3 months, with just 2,600 free subscribers.

"I said, I only want to get to 80 people. And you said, no, you're going to go bestseller. And I said, I don't think so."

That's what Neera told me on our live about our first goal-setting coaching call.

Three months later she had the badge.

Neera runs Author Circle. She helps people find their book, write it, publish it, and build a business around it. She's been on Substack since November 2020. Six years. And she hasn't missed a single week in all that time.

But she was stuck at around 950 subscribers for a long time. Writing whatever she felt like. Making no offers. Hoping that one day it would just... happen.

It didn't. Until she changed three things.

In this live we unpacked all of it.

Here's the breakdown.

Six years of consistency, and almost nothing to show for it

Neera found Substack the way many of us did (me included): through someone on Medium. She was fighting WordPress and MailChimp at the time, with 10 subscribers, most of them family.

So she moved. And set herself one goal: can I write and send a weekly newsletter?

She could. Every single week, for six years.

For about four and a half of those years she had zero intention to monetize. In one year she wrote a book every quarter, just for the joy of it, to nurture her creativity.

And that's completely fine.

Until mid-2025, when she noticed something. People who joined Substack much, much later than her were building six-figure businesses.

"I'm sitting on something and I'm not doing anything with it."

That was her a-ha moment.

So here’s what she did to fix that.

Fix #1: Teach what you're learning

The first thing was growth. She was sitting at 950-980 subscribers and going backwards, then a few up, then backwards again.

So she built a program around the exact thing she was trying to figure out: Write, Grow, Monetize. One month on each. She researched it, wrote about it, ran it as a cohort. People joined. And paid.

And her list doubled. 2,000+ subscribers within four to five months.

But here's the thing.

Teaching Substack growth wasn't her niche. There were people with way bigger audiences teaching the same thing, and, as Neera said herself, they were the better choice for that.

Her strength (and passion) was books. The moments she enjoyed most were helping someone else write theirs.

So she made the shift.

Fix #2: Write the book first, then build the business on it

So in late 2025 she drafted One Book to 100K.

The idea behind it is old. Napoleon Hill did it. People have been writing a book and building a business on top of it for over a century. Neera just flipped the order most new writers believe in.

Most of us think: get experience, build the business, then write the book.

Neera says: write the book first, and use it as your client attractor.

Because a book does two things:

  • It gives you authority. She'd written hundreds of articles across Substack, Medium and her website for five years, and none of them made her an authority on anything. One book did.

  • It gives you endless content. She used to panic every week about what to write. Now she has at least 10 posts sitting in drafts. She went from one post a week to three, plus a weekly live.

And people start associating your name with your niche.

That's positioning.

Then she tested the concept before scaling it. In January she announced a cohort: 10 spots, write your book in 30 days. Eight people joined. Many of them finished their book in 30 days and published it within 90.

She had proof. She ran more cohorts throughout the year.

Her advice to anyone arriving on Substack right now (and everyone is arriving, from LinkedIn, YouTube, TikTok, X):

You won't stand out unless you do two things. Become an authority on something. And stay in your niche.

Fix #3: Make offers. Every month.

This is where we came in.

Neera had the niche. She had the book, the program, the proof. But she was still doing what most writers do.

"I was just hoping people will join and one day I will become a bestseller. And no, it doesn't happen that way."

If you're not making offers consistently, people don't join.

That’s when we started working together.

So we set some automations and started some campaigns.

And the part I'll never forget: she hated writing sales emails. Dreaded them. She felt like she was becoming small by asking people to buy.

If you hate writing sales emails, know this: I see you. I was there too. I have 20+ years in marketing and sales, and the first time I had to write a sales email for my own offer, with no corporate brand behind me, it was a blank page.

What changed for Neera was the frame. Writing a book changed her life. If she's offering that to someone, with proof and testimonials, she's offering a life-changing experience. Not a just a product or a service.

And if someone unsubscribes after a sales email? They're not your people. They won’t buy from you anyway. Let them go. That's how you clean your audience and build a list of buyers.

The result

Bestseller badge within three months of working together. She wrote about it here:

Author Circle
How I Became a Substack Bestseller with Just 2,600 Subscribers
I wrote on Substack every week for five years…
Read more

With 2,700 free subscribers. She hadn't even hit her own goal of 3,000.

Truth is, you don't need 20,000 people to become a bestseller or build a business. A smaller list is actually better. You know your readers. You DM them, read their stories, see where they need help.

She came to me because she could see a system working. I have a video about how mine works here:

What you can take away from Neera's story

  1. Consistency alone isn't a business. Six years without missing a week got her a loyal list of ~950. Offers turned it into income.

  2. Pick the niche where your strength and your passion overlap, even if you first test something else.

  3. Create the authority asset. For Neera it's a book. It gave her positioning and more content ideas than she can write.

  4. Validate small. Eight people in one cohort was enough proof to build on.

  5. Make offers every month, with a real campaign behind them. Expect the sales to come at the end.

  6. Learn one skill at a time. One month, one skill, everything else waits.

And if you're thinking about writing a book, go subscribe to Neera Mahajan. Her program walks you through seven levels: build your skills, write the book, publish it, and build a business on it.

Neera, congratulations! On your way to the 1,000.

Yana

P.S. Neera said it best on that live: "If you want to make a mark on Substack, you need me before you need Yana." The offer comes first. If you already have one and want the system to sell it, this is where it all started.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?